The Marshalls : Katie Belle , Louis & Bea ca. 1930 W. Marshall coll. 2. James, b. 1862, m. Hattie Carr , dau. of John Carr . 3 s., Lawrence, Merrill, Charles. Children of Robert and Cordelia (Kielly) Marshall 1. Herbert, b. 24 May, 1873, d. 9 Aug., 1970, m. 26 Sept., 1908 by Rev. Spencer to Christina Elizabeth (Bessie) McGregor from , Montague (b. 30 Apr., 1873, d. 9 Aug., 1937), 1 c, Cordelia Ann , b. 24 Aug., 1909, m. 17 Aug., 1932 in Saskatoon to Jim MacKie , 2 sons. 2. Belle b. 18 Feb., 1875, d. 9 Mar., 1895. 3. Frank, b. 16 Nov., 1876, d. 8 Dec, 1942. m. 1. Matilda Brodie (9 June, 1889 - 23 June, 1915), dau. of James and Matilda (Carr) Brodie, 2 c, Belle and Edgar, see below, m. 2. Helen (Abbott) MacKinnon, 1 son, Ira. 4. Ida, b. 21 May, 1878, d. 19 May, 1966, m. 11 Oct., 1900 to Coles Bell (6 July, 1866 - 16 July 1942) 4 c, Roy, Lloyd, George and Frank. See Bell family history. 5. Charles, b. 11 Sept., 1880, d. 1962, unmarried. 6. Robert ( Bob ), b. Nov., 1882, d. 10 Nov., 1902, unmarried. 7. Walter, b. 3 June, 1886, d. 13 July, 1958, m. 28 Sept., 1927 to his cousin Cassie Douglas (b. 21 Sept., 1892), dau. of George and Charlotte (Marshall) Douglas. No c. 8. Art, b. 10 Aug., 1888, d. 1938, m. Martha Irving , lived in Charlottetown , 1 son 424