CONTENTS I. Introduction 3 2. A Letter from the Rev. Donald McDonald Corrects a Report in the Guardian on the Manner of His Meeting with the Delegation from the Established Church of Scotland. 6 3. The Rev John McMillan , Member of the Deputation from the Free Church of Scotland, Reports to the Colonial Committee on his Visit to British . 9 4. A Correspondent to the Presbyterian Witness writes in Defence of the Rev. Donald McDonald 1 1 5. The Rev. George Harper , Travelling Missionary for the Church of Scotland, Writes on MacDonald and MacDonalites to the Monthly Record. 13 6. The Rev. Alexander MacKay of Belfast, P.E.I Reveals to the Monthly Record His First Impressions of the Rev Donald McDonald 15 7. The Presbyterian Witness Describes the Reception Given to the Rev Donald McDonald at a Meeting of the Synod at St James Church, Charlottetown , June 30, 1858 16 8 The Presbyterian Witness' Reports on the Synod of 1859 in which the Rev McDonald Is Verbally "Assaulted' by the Rev Alexander MacKay of Belfast . 22 9. The Monthly Record Notices the Death of the Rev Donald McDonald . 24 10. The Prince Edward Island Presbytery Calls a Meeting to Choose a Successor to the Rev. Donald McDonald . 25 11. The Rev. James McColl Refers to the Rev Donald McDonald in a Report on his Own Missionary Labours. 27